Insurance News

Car Insurance Refund: Florida Orders $122.6 Million Back to Drivers of Three Insurers

About The Author: · Published

Charles Falcon is a pen name used by the sole author and publisher of VerifiedAgent.com. AI tools assist with research, organization, and drafting. The author is responsible for checking sources, reviewing the final text, and correcting errors. AI assistance is not independent editorial review.

A car insurance refund of $122.6 million is going to Florida drivers insured by Cimarron, Liberty Mutual or Security National, covering 2023 through 2025.

Florida Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky announced the refunds on November 19, 2026. The money covers calendar and accident years 2023, 2024 and 2025. The insurers must process refunds or renewal credits within 60 days, according to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation announcement issued that day.

What the November 19 Orders Require

The orders direct three insurers to return excess profits to applicable policyholders. The announced amounts are listed below.

Three abstract blue columns or pillars of different heights with shield motifs

Insurer Amount returned to policyholders
Cimarron Insurance, Inc. $908,149
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company $73,139,740
Security National Insurance Company $48,628,580

The three amounts total just over $122.6 million. Combined with the earlier order, the state reports more than $168 million in excess profit refunds to policyholders this year.

Commissioner Yaworsky encouraged other companies to review their books. Florida previously ordered Infinity Auto Insurance Company to return over $46 million. The earlier November 2 order covered the same calendar and accident years, 2023 through 2025.

Who Qualifies, and Who Does Not

The refund applies to Florida private passenger automobile business. It includes both voluntary and joint underwriting association business. Commercial auto policies are not included.

Under the statute, the excess amount is refunded pro rata in relation to final compilation year earned premiums to policyholders of record on December 31 of that final year. For this refund, the final compilation year is 2025. The allocation therefore tracks the applicable household's premium in 2025, rather than combining the household's premiums over all three years.

A household that paid more premium in 2025 has a larger pro rata share. Someone who has since switched insurers or canceled a policy can still be owed money. The policyholder-of-record date and applicable business classification determine the allocation under the stated rule.

No per-policyholder amount has been published. Available records identify the total amounts assigned to each insurer, but do not confirm an individual household's eligibility or payment amount. Policy and payment details should be independently confirmed with the insurer.

How Florida Calculates an Excessive Profit

The statutory test is described in section 627.066, Florida Statutes. Excessive profit exists when underwriting gain for the three most recent calendar-accident years combined is greater than anticipated underwriting profit plus 5 percent of earned premiums for those years.

Each insurer group must file the required data with the office by July 1 each year, using prescribed forms. Group filings consolidate information from the individual insurers in that group. The data covers Florida private passenger automobile business, including voluntary and joint underwriting association business.

If the test shows excessive profit, the office must order the excess returned after giving the insurer an opportunity for a hearing. Refunds are required unless the insurer affirmatively shows that returning the money would render a member of the group financially impaired or insolvent. The announced amounts are the insurer-level totals. The statute's test does not establish a uniform payment amount for every policyholder.

What Happens if the Check Never Arrives

The statute requires cash refunds to be completed within 60 days of a final order. If the insurer elects a renewal credit, that credit must be applied to premium notices sent more than 60 calendar days after the final order. An insured who cancels or allows the policy to terminate after the renewal-credit election is due a cash refund within 60 days of termination.

All three companies will attempt to locate policyholders whose checks are returned. If money cannot be delivered, it is reported and processed as unclaimed or abandoned property under Chapter 717 of Florida Statutes.

Abstract laptop search screen for unclaimed property with a blue protective shield and Florida map outline

The state's unclaimed property program provides a free search. There is no deadline to claim property, and the state never becomes the owner of the property. The program states that it will never text a claimant about a claim. Any unclaimed money related to these refunds is subject to those reporting and processing requirements.

What the Refund Is Not

A refund of past underwriting gains is not a rate reduction. It does not change what a household pays on a 2027 renewal. It is a one-time return covering 2023 through 2025, ordered under a profit threshold.

The auto refund is separate from the homeowners rate decreases the state has announced this fall. These are distinct actions and apply to different insurance coverage.

A household seeking a lower premium still has to compare rates and quotes. The state publishes a rate comparison tool for that purpose, and a policyholder can ask a licensed agent to run alternatives. A refund on past premiums does not carry into the price of a future policy.

A Timeline for Florida Policyholders

  • November 19, 2026: Refunds announced and orders issued.
  • Within 60 days: Cash payment or renewal credit due under the applicable payment method. This puts the outside date in mid-January 2027.
  • After a renewal credit election: If the policyholder cancels or coverage terminates, cash is due within 60 days of termination.
  • After location attempts fail: Undeliverable money is reported and processed as unclaimed or abandoned property.

The payment method and timing for a particular policyholder depend on the insurer's election and applicable policy status. Individual amounts and payment dates have not been published.

Five Questions to Ask Before You Count the Money

  1. Is the household's policy private passenger auto coverage with Cimarron, Liberty Mutual or Security National?
  2. Which three-year window and final compilation year apply to the policy?
  3. Will the payment arrive as a check or as a renewal credit?
  4. What steps apply if the household moved or changed carriers?
  5. Is the current premium still competitive once the credit runs out?

These questions distinguish the announced insurer-level refund pool from a confirmed household payment. Individual eligibility, amount and delivery status should be confirmed with the insurer.

How Licensed Help Works in Florida

Florida coverage advice comes from agents licensed and appointed in Florida. A license does not carry across state lines. A National Producer Number identifies a license record, and state-based records are organized by state. Available Florida agent and license records provide directory information; current licensing and appointment status should be independently confirmed.